More Sermons in Pinatas

(This week’s WOW is adapted and updated from a Christmas WOW post of a few years ago. I hope you’ll agree it’s worth reposting.)

In Shakespeare’s play “As You Like It,” Duke Senior, living in exile deep in the Forest of Ardenne, optimistically announces to his men that he “finds tongues in trees, books in the running brooks, sermons in stones, and good in everything” (Act II, scene 1).

I’ve always found this scene to be particularly inspiring. So I tend to search for sermons in unorthodox places – not just in a church on a Sunday morning.

On my frequent walks in Parque Juarez, here in San Miguel de Allende, for example, I ask the 100-year-old palm trees — their long arms reaching down to the walking/jogging path — what they can teach me. Be supple, I like to think they’re responding. Bend. Sway.

A pathway in Parque Juarez

And the stones? This old, colonial city in the central mountains of Mexico is made of stone – cobblestone streets, stone slab sidewalks, stone walls, stone archways and churches, stone homes. (They say this city will never go up in flames because stones don’t burn.) What do all these stones preach to me? Withstand, they say. Weather the storms. Be strong. Endure.

The entrance to a casa near El Chorro

Lately, then, I’ve been inquiring of the decorative Christmastime piñatas hanging everywhere in el centro and being offered for sale in the mercado: What is your story, and what can I learn from it?, I silently ask them.

A few of the hundreds of pinatas for sale at the mercado this week

I did a little research and found that the piñata’s history dates back to Marco Polo, who is credited with discovering what we now call piñatas in Asia. He observed that the Chinese fashioned figures of animals, covered with colored paper and other adornments, to greet the New Year. When participants knocked the figure hard with sticks, seeds spilled out.

In the 14th century the custom then passed into Europe, where the first Sunday in Lent became “Piñata Sunday.” (The Italian word pignatta means “fragile pot.”) In Spain a clay container was decorated with ribbons, tinsel and fringed paper and used in a fiesta called “The Dance of the Piñata.”

Spanish missionaries to Mexico tried to introduce the piñata in an effort to attract converts to their ceremonies – only to find that the indigenous people already had similar traditions.

To celebrate the birthday of their god of war, Huitzilopochtli, Aztec priests placed a clay pot on a pole in the temple at the year’s end. Colorful feathers adorned the richly decorated pot, filled with tiny treasures. When it was broken with a stick or club, those treasures fell to the ground. Mayans also played a similar game in which the players’ eyes were covered while hitting a clay pot suspended by string.

The Spanish missionaries transformed these games for religious instruction, and these beliefs have continued in large part to today. Seven-pointed piñatas symbolize the seven deadly sins (envy, sloth, gluttony, greed, lust, wrath, and pride). The stick used to break the piñata symbolizes love. And the candies and treats that pour from the broken piñata symbolize the forgiveness of sins and a new beginning.

The sermon I’m hearing in my heart now from these festive Mexican holiday piñatas goes something like this: Keep reaching up. Keep striving. Keep thwacking in blind faith. There may well be blessings and surprises – “tiny treasures” — in store in the coming year.

11 thoughts on “More Sermons in Pinatas”

  1. Well, this made my day. I was just telling friends here in Oakland about the beautiful 7-pointed pinatas that are everywhere at this time of year. Before I left SMA, I bought papier mache Christmas tree decorations in the shape of those pinatas. Now I can share their fascinating history. Felice Navidad Amiga.

    1. So happy to have made your day, querida Kim! Yes, this was an old (4 y.o.) post, but still timely, I think. It’s an old and enduring tradition to thwack pinatas! 🙂 Feliz Navidad to you and family too. — xx

  2. I love this! I love how you look for messages and lessons in everything and find beauty in the small things. Merry Christmas and may the new year bring you love, joy and peace.

    1. Your kind words touch me deeply, dear Kimberly! Thank you. And I wish all the same for you and your family — during this holiday season and in the coming new year. — BB

    1. Y Feliz Navidad to you and Gary, querida Te! I saw our mutual friend Theresa Taggarts here in SMA recently for lunch. We spoke of you! Now it’s your turn to come here… Maybe in 2022 at last? — Abrazos, BB

  3. It’s posts like these that have kept you close to my heart all these years. Lessons learned! Sway and bend yet stand strong and endure. I’ve been thwacking at life ever since I can remember, I’m not gonna stop now. Thank you for sharing these inspirational thoughts and for the historical background. Wishing you ever happiness, dear Bonnie, for the holiday and every day! xoxo

    1. Ah, MM, you’ve made my day! Thank you for taking the time from your busy life to write this. It’s struck like a love-arrow in my heart. I, of course, wish you the same wishes — for this holiday season, this coming new year, and all the years to come! — LU, BB xx

  4. Dear Bon,

    We need all to take a lesson from you and learn from the natural and everyday things we encounter. Rather than seeing these things as objects or not really seeing them at all, we should all try to understand what they are saying to us.
    Unfortunately, not all are gifted with your acute ability to observe and innate talent for turning observations into human truths. These are a writer’s gifts, and it’s what gives your words such authentic power. What you wrote here is a more life-affirming sermon than most of what I’ve heard in any church.


    1. Thank you, my dearest Paul, for your super-kind words. But I must give the credit to Shakespeare and his memorable line, “sermons in stones.” I stole the idea from him. 🙂 Wishing you a wonderful holiday season and all the best in 2022. Maybe you’ll come and visit me? — LU & Miss you, BB xx

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.